Landlord disputes

Dispute over renting a home? There are always options!

A dispute with your landlord can be expensive: even an initial consultation with a lawyer costs up to 190 € plus VAT, and a court case over the deposit or utility costs can run to hundreds or thousands of euros. It is especially hard for people who have only recently moved to Germany. Many run into problems in their very first flat: no experience, limited German, and no shortage of unscrupulous landlords.

Legal expenses insurance with a housing module – Mietrechtsschutz – protects you in advance. Below: what it covers, what it costs, why you should take it out before a dispute and what to do if a dispute has already started.

What Mietrechtsschutz covers

The insurance pays lawyer, court and expert fees in disputes about a rented home. Typical cases:

Disputes about buying or building a home and about inheritance are not covered by this module. The excess (Selbstbeteiligung) is usually 150 € per case – the option Stiftung Warentest recommends.

Waiting period: why you should take out the insurance early

Legal expenses insurance only covers future disputes. If the cause of the dispute arose before the policy started or during the waiting period (Wartezeit), the insurer does not pay. For Mietrechtsschutz the waiting period is usually 3 months, with some insurers 6.

So it is best to take out the insurance when you sign the tenancy agreement, not when a disputed Nebenkosten bill arrives.

The dispute has already started: what to do

How much Mietrechtsschutz costs

According to Stiftung Warentest, a stand-alone policy for rental disputes only costs around 100 € a year. The housing module is available on its own or in a package with private, employment and traffic legal protection. The price depends on the insurer, the excess and the modules you choose.

For tenants and for landlords

As a tenant, you insure disputes about the home you live in. If you rent out a flat yourself, you need separate landlord legal protection (Vermieter-Rechtsschutz) for that property: it covers disputes over rent arrears, utility costs and eviction. Tenant insurance does not cover these disputes.

Alternative: a Mieterverein

A Mieterverein is a tenants’ association. As a member, you get:

Membership usually costs €50–90 a year, and many associations already include insurance for court proceedings. You can find one by searching for “Mieterverein e.V. + your city”. You can join even after a dispute has started: the association’s lawyers will advise you on it, but the court-costs insurance included in the membership will not cover that dispute.

Find the right Mietrechtsschutz

Fill in the questionnaire and we will find a tariff with the housing module, on its own or in a package. It only takes a few minutes.

If you are not sure which modules you need, book a free consultation.

Frequently asked questions

Usually not: the waiting period is 3 months, with some insurers 6. Exceptions are possible if you switch from another legal expenses insurance policy without a gap – this is set out in the policy terms, and we check it when choosing a tariff.

A standard policy does not: it only covers future disputes. The exception is ARAG Mietrechtsschutz Sofort: it covers one dispute that began no more than 12 months before the policy started, and the contract runs for 3 years. Disputes over mould or building defects and most notices of termination are not covered. If the dispute is already under way, the Mieterbund hotline, Beratungshilfe or an initial consultation with a lawyer can also help.

Around 100 € a year for a stand-alone policy that covers rental disputes only (Stiftung Warentest). In a package with other modules, the price is different.

A Mieterverein gives advice and often includes insurance for court proceedings – usually for €50–90 a year. With your own policy, you choose your lawyer yourself and can add other modules: employment, traffic and private legal protection.

No, you need landlord legal protection (Vermieter-Rechtsschutz) for the flat you rent out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *